0

This question follows on from one I have previously asked, How to separate cubic equations into two conic sections: Deep dive into Omar Khayyam and I now would like some further advice on some particular forms of cubic equations.

The first case is an equation of the form: $ x^3 = ax^2 + bx + c $ being reduced to two hyperbolas.

The second case is an equation of the form: $ x^3 + bx = ax^2 +c $ being reduced to a hyperbola and a circle.

Thank you in advance for any help you could provide

Edit:

Equation of the form $x^3 + ax^2 + bx = c$ should apparently break down into a hyperbola and semicircle (meaning that its centre lies along either the x or y axis exactly) can the second example be extended to this case?

1 Answers1

1

Several different solutions are possible. I managed to find Khayyam's paper online and here are his solutions. Of course he used a purely geometrical language and gave his solution as a construction, followed by a proof that this was indeed right. I'll reverse his reasoning, as you seem to prefer, and use a more familiar language.

First case: $x^3=ax^2+bx+c$.

We can rewrite this equation as: $$ x^2(x-a)=b\left(x+{c\over b}\right) $$ and multiply both sides by $(x+{c/ b})$, obtaining: $$ \tag{1} x^2(x-a)\left(x+{c\over b}\right)=b\left(x+{c\over b}\right)^2. $$ If we set now: $$ \tag{2} y^2=(x-a)\left(x+{c\over b}\right), $$ which is the equation of a rectangular hyperbola, we can rewrite $(1)$ as: $$ x^2y^2=\left(\sqrt{b}x+{c\over \sqrt{b}}\right)^2. $$ But this is the square of $$ \tag{3} xy=\sqrt{b}x+{c\over \sqrt{b}}, $$ which is the equation of another rectangular hyperbola. Our equation is then equivalent to the system formed by $(2)$ and $(3)$.


Second case: $x^3+bx=ax^2+c$.

Set: $$ b=h^2,\quad c=sh^2 $$ and rewrite the equation as $$ h^2(x-s)=x^2(a-x). $$ Now multiply both sides by $(x-s)$ (this will introduce the spurious solution $x=s$, which must be discarded) to obtain: $$ \tag{4} h^2(x-s)^2=x^2(a-x)(x-s). $$ If we set now: $$ \tag{5} (a-x)(x-s)=(h-y)^2, $$ which is the equation of a circle, and substitute into $(4)$, we get $$ h^2(x-s)^2=x^2(h-y)^2. $$ But this is the square of: $$ \tag{6} h(x-s)=x(h-y), $$ which is the equation of a rectangular hyperbola. The solution of the original equation can then be obtained as the abscissa of the second intersection between circle $(5)$ and hyperbola $(6)$, their first intersection being point $(s,h)$.

EDIT.

For the case $x^3+ax^2+bx=c$ Khayyam makes the same construction as in the case $x^3+bx=ax^2+c$ outlined above. Just make the substitution $a\to-a$ in the above explanation to find the corresponding hyperbola and circle.