It's already been noted that convergence follows readily from the
Prime Number Theorem (Adam Hughes), or even from less precise
estimates such as Mertens (Daniel Fischer; the Chebyshev bound
$p_k \gg k \log k$ would suffice too) $-$ but also that convergence
is frustratingly slow, with the sum over $p > x$ decaying only as $1/\log x$.
Here's another approach, via the Euler product
$$
\sum_{n=1}^\infty \frac1{n^s} =: \zeta(s) = \prod_p \frac1{1-p^{-s}}
$$
(the product extending over all primes $p$),
which makes it practical to estimate $\sum_p 1 / p \log p$ to high accuracy.
The numerical value turns out to be 1.636616323351260868569658...;
these days, once one has such a decimal expansion, Google will often find
a reference, and here the computation is reported in the arXiv preprint
Richard J. Mathar:
Twenty Digits of Some Integrals of the Prime Zeta Function
(preprint, 2008), arXiv: 0811.4738
(see Table 2.4 at the bottom of page 4).
Taking logarithms of the Euler product we find
$$
\log \zeta(s) = \sum_p -\log (1-p^{-s})
= \sum_p \frac1{p^s}
+ \sum_p \frac1{2p^{2s}}
+ \sum_p \frac1{3p^{3s}}
+ \cdots.
$$
We can isolate the first contribution $\sum_p 1/p^s$ by taking a suitable
linear combination of $\log \zeta(s)$, $\log \zeta(2s)$, $\log \zeta(3s)$, etc.,
finding
$$
\sum_p \frac1{p^s} = \sum_{m=1}^\infty \frac{\mu(m)}{m} \log \zeta(ms),
$$
where $\mu$ is the Möbius function.
Now since $1 / \log p = \int_1^\infty p^{-s} ds$, we can integrate
the formula for $\sum_p \frac1{p^s}$ to find
$$
\sum_p \frac1{p \log p}
= \sum_{m=1}^\infty \frac{\mu(m)}{m} \int_1^\infty \log \zeta(ms) \, ds
= \sum_{m=1}^\infty \frac{\mu(m)}{m^2} \int_m^\infty \log \zeta(s) \, ds.
$$
This clearly converges, because
$\int_m^\infty \log \zeta(ms)$ decays as $2^{-m}$ for large $m$, while
for $s=1+\epsilon$ we know that $\zeta(s)$ grows as $1/\epsilon$ so
$\log\zeta(s)$ grows only as $\log(1/\epsilon)$ which is integrable.
Moreover, we can evaluate $\zeta(s)$ (and $(s-1)\zeta(s)$ near $s=1$)
to high precision using Euler-Maclaurin summation of $\sum_{n=1}^\infty 1/n^s$.
This makes the formula amenable to known techniques for numerical integration.
One such technique is implemented in gp, and the command
sum(m=1,199,moebius(m)*intnum(s=m,200,log(zeta(s)))/m^2)
takes only a few seconds to return the numerical value reported above.