3

Context: This question is meant as an addendum to my question Does the sequence $1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6$ appear in the number of groups of order $n$ up to isomorphism? which I asked a while ago.

That question asked whether or not we could find an integer $n$ such that

$$\mathrm{gnu}(n+i) = i \quad i=1,...,6$$

where $\mathrm{gnu}(n)$ denotes the number of groups of order $n$ up to isomorphism.

It turns out you can, and I found $n = 29436120$ works.

I brute-forced a search for $n$ to find that, but what I didn't mention is I substantially reduced the possible $n$ I had to search by noting that $n$ has to be a multiple of $24$.

In particular, if

$$\mathrm{gnu}(n+i) = i \quad i=1,...,4$$

holds, then $24 \mid n$.

When I first submitted A373650 to the OEIS, which is the sequence containing the indexes of all the $1,2,3,4$s, someone named Hugo Pfoertner observed that all the terms I submitted are divisible by $24$. I'd only had that each term must be even at that point, so this sped up the search substantially. While I set up the search using this fact, I looked for a proof that this is true.

It is true, but I've never written up the proof in full anywhere. I thought would be a good idea to put it here, for completeness of the other question. Everything used in the proof is fairly elementary, but I think the steps in the proof are quite nice. Namely, we observe $2 \mid n$, then $4 \mid n$, then $8 \mid n$, then $3 \mid n$ successively, with each one of those observations hinging on the previous.

In fact, it's also possible to show:

  • $48 \not \mid n$ for any $n$
  • we can get further conditions on $n$ modulo various prime numbers, such as $5,7,11,13$

but that's a story for another time.

Robin
  • 6,201

1 Answers1

4

First, we'll need a few lemmas:

Lemma 1: If $a$, $b$ are coprime, then

$$\mathrm{gnu}(ab) \geq \mathrm{gnu}(a) \mathrm{gnu}(b).$$

Sketch of proof: Let $G_1, \dots G_n$ be nonisomorphic groups of order $a$, $H_1, \dots, H_m$, be nonisomoprhic groups of order $b$. Then we can show $(G_i \times H_j)_{i=1,...,n}^{j=1,...,m}$ are all nonisomorphic due to the coprimality of $a$ and $b$.

In fact, it is conjectured that the above holds for all $a, b$.

Lemma 2: For $p$ prime, $q$ coprime to $p$, $m > 1$, $\mathrm{gnu}(p^mq) \geq \mathrm{gnu}(p^{m-1}q)$. In particular, $\mathrm{gnu}(2^m) \geq 5$ for all $m \geq 3$.

Sketch of proof: Can be proved inductively by showing that the groups of the previous prime power order, direct product the cyclic group of order $p$, are all non-isomorphic. Second statement follows immediately after observing $\mathrm{gnu}(8)=5$.

Lemma 3: For $p$ an odd prime, $\mathrm{gnu}(4p) \geq 4$.

Sketch of proof: One can show $C_{4p}$, $C_{2} \times C_2 \times C_p$, $D_{4p}$, $\mathrm{Dic}_{4p}$ are all non-isomorphic, where $C_m$ is the cyclic group of order $m$, $D_m$ is the dihedral group of order $m$, $\mathrm{Dic}_m$ is the dicyclic group of order $m$.

Lemma 4: For $p$ an odd prime, $t \geq 1$, $\mathrm{gnu}(4p^t) \geq 4$.

Proof: If $t = 1$, this is just lemma 3. If $t \geq 1$,

$$ \begin{align} \mathrm{gnu}(4p^t) &\geq \mathrm{gnu}(4) \mathrm{gnu}(p^t) && \text{lemma 1}\\ &\geq \mathrm{gnu}(4) \mathrm{gnu}(p^2) && \text{lemma 2}\\ &\geq 2 \cdot 2 \\ &\geq 4. \end{align} $$


Now, we will successively show that $2 \mid n$, then $4 \mid n$, then $8 \mid n$, then $3 \mid n$.


$2 \mid n$:

In fact, this shows that if

$$\mathrm{gnu}(n+i) = i \quad i=1,...,2$$

holds, then $2 \mid n$.

Since $\mathrm{gnu}(n+1) = 1$, we have that either $n+1=2$ or $n+1$ is odd, as there exists a dihedral group of order $2m$ for all $m>2$, and $\mathrm{gnu}(4) = 2$.

But if $n=1$, $\mathrm{gnu}(n+2) = \mathrm{gnu}(3) = 1$.

So $n$ is even.


$4 \mid n$:

In fact, this shows that if

$$\mathrm{gnu}(n+i) = i \quad i=1,...,3$$

holds, then $4 \mid n$.

We already have $2 \mid n$, so suppose for contradiction $n \equiv 2 \mod 4$. Then $n + 2 \equiv 0 \mod 4$.

Write $n = 2^rs$ where $s$ is odd. We have $r \geq 2$. If $r \geq 3$

$$\begin{align} \mathrm{gnu}(n+2) &= \mathrm{gnu}(2^r s) \\ &\geq \mathrm{gnu}(2^r)\mathrm{gnu}(s) && \text{lemma 1} \\ &\geq \mathrm{gnu}(2^r) \\ &\geq 5 && \text{lemma 2} \\ \end{align}$$

which is a contradiction. $(\ast)$

So $r = 2$. As $m$ is odd, either $m=1$ or there is some odd prime $p \mid m$. Let $p^t$ be the largest power of $p$ dividing $m$, with $t \geq 1$. Then $n+2 = 4p^t u$ with $u$ coprime to $4, p^t$ and hence

$$\begin{align} \mathrm{gnu}(n+2) &= \mathrm{gnu}(4p^t u) \\ &\geq \mathrm{gnu}(4p^t) \mathrm{gnu}(u) && \text{lemma 1} \\ &\geq \mathrm{gnu}(4p^t) \\ &\geq 4 && \text{lemma 4} \end{align}$$

which is also a contradiction.

So, $4 \mid n$.


$8 \mid n$:

We have $4 \mid n$. Suppose $n = 4m$, for $m$ odd. Then $8 \mid n+4$. It follows similarly to how we previously argued at $(\ast)$ that $\mathrm{gnu}(n+4) \geq 5$, a contradiction. Hence $8 \mid n$.


$3 \mid n$:

We have $n = 8m$. Suppose $3 \not \mid m$ for contradiction.

Then $n+4 = 4(2m+1)$. $2m+1 \not \equiv 1 \mod 3$, as $m \not \equiv 0 \mod 3$.

Hence we can rewrite $n+4 = 4r$, $r$ odd, $r \not \equiv 1 \mod 3$.

If $r \equiv 0 \mod 3$, $12 \mid n+4$. Similarly to how we have previously argued using lemma 1 and lemma 2, we can show $\mathrm{gnu}(n+4) \geq \mathrm{gnu}(12) = 5$, a contradiction.

If $r \equiv 2 \mod 3$, then $n+4 = 4(3s+2) = 12s+8$ for some $s$.

But $n = 12s+4$, and $8 \mid n$, so we require $s = 2t+1$ is odd.

Hence $n = 12(2t+1)+4 = 24t+16$.

So $n+2 = 24t+18 = 6(4t+3)$.

If $3 \mid t$, then $18 \mid n+2$. Again we can argue with lemma 1 and lemma 2 that $\mathrm{gnu}(n+2) \geq \mathrm{gnu}(18) = 5$, a contradiction.

Otherwise, we have $n+2 = 6u$, for some $u$ with $2, 3 \not \mid u$. So there is a prime $p$ such that $6p \mid n+2$. Yet again, we argue with lemma 1 and 2 that $\mathrm{gnu}(n+2) \geq \mathrm{gnu}(6p)$.

But then, $C_2 \times C_3 \times C_p$, $C_3 \times D_{2p}$, $C_p \times D_6$, $D_{6p}$ can all be shown to be non-isomorphic groups of order $6p$. Thus, $\mathrm{gnu}(n+2) \geq 4$, another contradiction.

Hence, we have $3 \mid n$.


As $3 \mid n$ and $8 \mid n$, we have $24 \mid n$ as required.

Robin
  • 6,201