3

I'd like to ask whether any closed ideal $I$ of the space $C(K)$, where $K$ is an arbitrary compact metric space, is complemented. By complemented I mean that there is a bounded projection $P\colon C(K)\to C(K)$ whose range is exaclty $I$. Of course it is well-known that every such ideal is of the form $\{f\in C(K) : f|_C = 0\}$ for some closed subset $C\subseteq K$.

Thank you very much!

Tomasz Kania
  • 16,996
  • 3
    This might be of help to you, considering $C(K)$ is a separable $C^\star$-algebra when $K$ is metrisable: https://mathoverflow.net/q/271293 – Bruno B Nov 27 '24 at 12:52
  • 3
    Yes, thank you - I saw this but I didn't look in depth enough... the mentioned paper (https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/002212367490010X) by Andersen, 1973, in that question, on its first page says `in an abelian C*-algebra with unit a closed two-sided ideal is complemented if the quotient is separable.'. This solves my question. Thanks a lot :) – Filip_pp Nov 27 '24 at 15:55

1 Answers1

3

The answer is positive for metrisable spaces:

Since any ideal $I$ is determined by a closed set $S\subseteq K$, we have $C(K) / I$ naturally isomorphic to $C(L)$. However, since $K$ is metrisable, the Borsuk-Dugundji theorem yields a contractive linear extension operator $u\colon C(S)\to C(K)$ so that $u(f)|_S = f$ for $f\in C(S)$. This means that the quotient $C(K)/I$ is complemented in $C(K)$ via $Pf = u(f|_S)$. Consequently, $Q = \operatorname{id}-P$ is a projection onto $I$. To see this, take $f\in C(K)$ so that $f$ is zero on $S$. Then $u(f|_S)=0$ as $u$ is linear so it maps zero to zero. Thus $Qf = f - 0 = f$.

The answer is negative for non-metrisable spaces:

To see this, consider $K = \beta N$, the Čech–Stone compactification of the discrete space of natural numbers. The remainder $L = \beta N \setminus N$ is closed but there is no projection onto the associated ideal as otherwise $c_0$ would be complemented in $\ell_\infty$. You may read this post to see why (This is the so-called Phillips-Sobczyk theorem.)

A stronger no is possible too as there exist spaces $K$ so that only finite-dimensional and finite-codimensional subspaces of $C(K)$ are complemented; see this thread. The first such space was constructed by Piotr Koszmider.

Tomasz Kania
  • 16,996