3

Let $G$ a non-abelian simple group and let $A=\mathrm{Inn}(G)$ and $B=\mathrm{Aut}(G)$. I would like to know the solution to $A\,\operatorname{char}\, B$. However, I know the following. Let $\phi \in \mathrm{Aut}(B)$.

a) $\phi(A) \cong A \cong G/Z(G) \cong G$ is simple.

b) $A \cap \phi(A)$ is normal in $\phi(A)$.

c) Since a) and b), $A \cap \phi(A) = \{ \rm{id}_G \}$ or $\phi(A)$.

Therefore, I only want to know $A \cap \phi(A) \neq \{ \rm{id}_G \}$.

Akasa
  • 101

2 Answers2

4

$\def\Inn{\operatorname{Inn}}$$\def\Aut{\operatorname{Aut}}$Let $G$ be a group with $Z(G) = 1$. Write $i_g$ for the inner automorphism $i_g(x) = gxg^{-1}$, and observe that $\phi i_g \phi^{-1} = i_{\phi(g)}$ for any $g \in G$ and $\phi \in\Aut(G)$. Therefore if $\phi$ commutes with each $i_g \in \Inn(G)$, i.e., $\phi \in C_{\Aut(G)}(\Inn(G))$, it follows that $i_g = i_{\phi(g)}$ for all $g \in G$, whence $\phi(g) = g$ since $Z(G)$ is trivial. Therefore the centralizer $C_{\Aut(G)}(\Inn(G))$ is trivial.

Now assume $G$ is simple. We claim that $\Inn(G) \cong G$ is characteristic in $\Aut(G)$. Let $\psi \in \Aut(\Aut(G))$, let $I = \Inn(G)$, and let $J = \psi(\Inn(G))$. Then $I \cong J \cong G$ and $I, J \trianglelefteq \Aut(G)$, so $I \cap J$ is either $I$ or trivial (as explained by OP). In the latter case we have $[I,J] \le I \cap J = 1$, so $J \le C_{\Aut(G)}(I) = 1$, a contradiction.

Bonus: It follows that we have a natural map $\Aut(\Aut(G)) \to \Aut(\Inn(G)) \cong \Aut(G)$ defined by restriction. The first paragraph above shows that (a) this map is injective, since its kernel is $C_{\Inn(G)}(\Aut(G)) = 1$, and (b) this map is surjective, since the inner automorphism $i_\phi \in \Inn(\Aut(G))$ maps to $\phi \in \Aut(G)$. Therefore $\Aut(\Aut(G)) = \Inn(\Aut(G)) \cong \Aut(G)$.

This is all essentially abstract nonsense and it is not necessary to use any deep facts about finite simple groups such as Schreier's hypothesis. In fact we do not need to assume $G$ is finite.

Shaun
  • 47,747
Sean Eberhard
  • 12,209
2

A famous conjecture of Otto Schreier states that for every finite simple group, Aut$(G)$/Inn$(G)$ (a.k.a. Out$(G)$) is always solvable. The conjecture was proved to be true as a consequence of the classification of finite simple groups. Therefore Inn$(G)$ is in fact the unique subgroup isomorphic to $G$ inside Aut$(G)$, whence characteristic: if $H$ would be another subgroup of Aut$(G)$ isomorphic to, but different from Inn$(G)$, then, since $H$ is non-abelian simple, and Inn$(G) \unlhd $ Aut$(G)$, $H \cap $Inn$(G)=1$. But then $H \cong H/H \cap $Inn$(G) \cong H \cdot $Inn$(G)/$Inn$(G)$ is solvable, a contradiction.

Nicky Hekster
  • 52,147
  • Thank you for your response.If you'd like please tell me a solution in the case of infinate group. – Akasa Apr 17 '24 at 10:43
  • 4
    There was no assumption in the question that the group is finite. But this raises the interesting question of whether there are infinite simple groups $G$ such that ${\rm Aut}(G)$ has a subgroup isomorphic to $G$ other than ${\rm Inn}(G)$. – Derek Holt Apr 17 '24 at 15:34