9

The standard configuration of Brunnian "rubberband" loops shows a series of unknots each bent into a U-shape, with their ends looped around the middle of the next unknot, as shown here (drawn by David Epstein) Brunnian rubberband loop object:

enter image description here

This has the defining Brunnian link property that all elements are interlocked, but the removal of any element causes all the others to disentangle. But it requires each element to link to the next with 8 cross-overs, and be bent around so as to form a minimum of four bights along its "length".

I have been playing around with an object that I call an "exaltation of larks", since it is based on lark's-head knots to connect the elements. This reduces the number of cross-overs to 6 per pair, and allows for each element to have only two bights along its length. A visual is here exaltation of larks object:

enter image description here

This also seems to fulfill the Brunnian definition, and is substantially simpler. I am wondering if (1) this object is already known and has another name, and/or (2) the object is not Brunnian for some reason I have overlooked. Thanks! (First time here...)

Added 12/22/21:

I've done a pretty good look-back in the papers at this point, and here's what I've come up with. Dale Rolfsen describes a Brunnian link which is equivalent to a five-element "exaltation of larks" (p. 69, exercise 15, Knots and Links, 1976). This is cited directly in at least one other place ("New Criteria and Construction of Brunnian Links" by Sheng Bai and Weibiao Wang https://arxiv.org/pdf/2006.10290.pdf). None of those authors note that this is a simpler version of the Brunnian chain than the standard, and most compendiums of Brunnian links do not show this pattern at all.

So I think I have what I need here, thanks for the help!

egmoen
  • 91
  • 1
    Welcome to MSE. It does look like you have a Brunnian link there. And it does seem to have 6 crossings per component. I have not seen it before, but that doesn't mean it is unknown. What were you looking to do with this object? If you need to use for some project, you can email David Epstein and ask if he knows about it, if you are planning on trying to publish something. – N. Owad Dec 21 '21 at 15:25
  • Sorry, I know nothing about this. I don't remember ever drawing anything like this. What is the source of this story? Most likely it is by another David Epstein, not this one (University of Warwick, England) – David Epstein Dec 21 '21 at 20:53
  • Well, it looks like knot atlas has a page where they draw almost the same thing. Maybe this is actually from Dror Bar-Natan. Try asking him? – N. Owad Dec 22 '21 at 16:01
  • 2
    Do you have a proof that your link is not trivial? (tried HOMFLY, but I was lost in the computations) – Anton Petrunin Jul 10 '22 at 10:50

0 Answers0