1

I'm looking for cool, competition-style problems that borrow ideas from physics in their solution. For example, one I found in the book Putnam and Beyond goes like this:

Orthogonal to each face of a polyhedron $S$ construct an outward vector with length numerically equal to the area of the face. Prove that the sum of all these vectors is equal to zero.

Solution:

Assume that the interior $V$ of polyhedron $S$ is filled with gas at a (not necessarily constant) pressure $p$. The force that the gas exerts on S is $\int\int_S p \:\hat{n} \: dA$, where $\hat{n}$ is the outward normal vector to the surface of the polyhedron and $dA$ is the area element. The divergence theorem implies that $$\int \int_S p\:\hat{n}\: dA = \int\int\int_V \nabla p \:dV$$ Here $\nabla p$ denotes the gradient of $p$. If the pressure p is constant, then the right-hand side is equal to zero. This is the case with our polyhedron, where $p = 1$. The double integral is exactly the sum of the vectors under discussion, these vectors being the forces exerted by pressure on the faces.

I realize that, in retrospect, it is possible to purge any physics from this solution by just jumping straight to the divergence theorem, but regardless I like the fact that you can use a physical analogy (interpreting the vectors on the faces of the polyhedron as forces) to intuit a solution. What are some other problems of this sort?


Comment 1: I asked long ago whether a request for questions was on-topic, and got a tentative yes.

Comment 2: There are a few concepts from physics which I am confident can be used to good effect for pure math problems. I'll mention a few in case it jogs someone's memory and helps them recall such a problem:

  • The use of entropy/energy as a monotonic quantity in differential equations.
  • Pauli matrices for rotations
  • The concept of thermodynamic equilibrium (as used by Einstein to derive spontaneous emission coefficients).
  • Fermat's principle for finding solutions to variational problems (as in the Brachistochrone problem).

Of course I also welcome problems that do not use these ideas!

Yly
  • 15,791
  • Soap bubbles. https://math.berkeley.edu/~sethian/2006/Applications/MinimalSurfaces/minimal.html – irchans Jul 08 '19 at 01:19
  • I just posted a problem on retrograde motion. The problem contains a function $f(r)$. According to physics $f(r)=f(1/r)r^{3/2}$, but I have only been able to verify this numerically. Here is a link to the post https://math.stackexchange.com/questions/3286306/is-this-retrograde-motion-function-analytic-at-r-1 – irchans Jul 08 '19 at 01:29
  • 1
    You can't do better than The Mathematical Mechanic: Using Physical Reasoning to Solve Problems, by Mark Levi. https://smile.amazon.com/Mathematical-Mechanic-Physical-Reasoning-Problems/dp/0691154562/ref=sr_1_2?crid=1B9LRZHXDZ51V&keywords=mathematical+mechanic&qid=1562551155&s=gateway&sprefix=mathematical+mech%2Caps%2C172&sr=8-2 – Adrian Keister Jul 08 '19 at 01:59
  • Duplicate of a similar question : https://mathoverflow.net/questions/46883/examples-of-using-physical-intuition-to-solve-math-problems – Jean Marie Aug 21 '19 at 00:54
  • As well duplicate of https://math.stackexchange.com/q/457/305862 (in which one finds the pressure solution for the polyhedron) – Jean Marie Aug 21 '19 at 00:58

0 Answers0