Let $n_1 < \dotsb < n_k$ and $m_1, \dotsc, m_k$ be integers. Can we find conditions for the existence polynomial $p$ with integer coefficients such that $p(n_i) = m_i$ for every $i$?
This isn't always possible: for example, since $p(i) \equiv p(0) \mod{i}$, we cannot have $p(0) = 0$ and $p(2) = 1$.
By this answer, if such a polynomial exists then the Lagrange interpolating polynomial has integer coefficients, so the question may be restated as when does the Lagrange interpolating polynomial have integer coefficients.