13

Consider a cryptographic hash function that maps $n$-bit strings to $n$-bit strings:

$$ \DeclareMathOperator{\H}{H} \DeclareMathOperator{\SHA}{SHA-256} \H(x) : \left\{0,1\right\}^{n} \mapsto \left\{0,1\right\}^{n}. $$

Let $\H^i$ denote the result of iterating $\H$ $i$ times, i.e., $\H^1 = \H$, $\H^2 = \H \circ \H$, etc.

Suppose we choose $x \in \{0,1\}^n$ uniformly at random. What is the estimated amount of entropy in $\H^i(x)$? I'm most interested in the case $n=128$.

More specifically, I'm particularly interested in the following special case. Define a hash function $\H$ by truncating the output of $\SHA$ to $128$ bits, i.e.,

$$ \H(x) = \SHA\left(x\right)\mid_{128} $$

With this definition of $\H$, what is the entropy of $\H^i(x)$ now, when $x$ is chosen uniformly at random from $\{0,1\}^{128}$? Does $\H$ maintain 128 bits of preimage resistance from $\SHA$, or is it significantly weakened? Are any other security properties of the underlying hash function weakened?

D.W.
  • 36,982
  • 13
  • 107
  • 196
Stephen Touset
  • 11,162
  • 1
  • 39
  • 53

1 Answers1

10

My estimate of the entropy after $i$ iterations is roughly $128- \lg i$ bits (as $i$ grows large). I don't have a proof of this, but I'll lay out my rough back-of-the-envelope calculations below.

Here is the general problem:

Problem 1. Let $F:\{0,1\}^n \to \{0,1\}^n$ be a random, i.e., chosen uniformly at random from the set of all functions with that signature. Let $F^i$ denote the result of iterating $F$ $i$ times. Let $X$ be uniformly distributed on $\{0,1\}^n$. Let $F$ be known to the adversary, and $X$ be secret. What is the entropy of $F^i(X)$?

I don't know how to solve that problem. But here is a related problem that I do know how to solve.

Problem 2. Let $F$ be as above. Let $f_i$ denote the fraction of $n$-bit values that can appear at the output of $F^i$. In other words, $f_i = |S_i|/2^n$, where we define $S_i$ to be the the set $S_i = \{F^i(x) : x\in \{0,1\}^n\}$ of all values that can appear as the output of $F$ iterated $i$ times. What is the value of $f_i$, as a function of $i$?

Note that the answer to the problem 2 gives us a heuristic rough estimate at the answer to problem 1. In particular, if we assume that $F^i(X)$ is approximately uniformly distributed on the set of all possible values (i.e., on $S_i$), then the entropy of $F^i(X)$ will be approximately $n - \lg f_i$.

And I can give you a reasonable solution to problem 2. In particular, using a crude heuristic, $f_i$ approximately satisfies the following recurrence relation:

$$f_{i+1} \approx 1 - e^{-f_i},$$

where $f_0 = 1$. The first few values of $f_i$ are $f_1=0.632$, $f_2=0.469$, $f_3=0.374$, $f_4=0.312$, $f_5=0.268$, $f_6=0.235$, $f_7=0.210$. This recurrence relation does break down when $i$ gets extremely large, certainly by the time $i$ reaches $2^{n/2}$ or so, but this might not be a major concern for the values of $i$ you care about in practice.

Asymptotically, when $i$ gets large enough (but not so large that it gets close to $2^{n/2}$), I think that a crude approximation to $f_i$ is

$$f_i \sim 2/i.$$

Thus, for large (but not too large) $i$, this gives us a crude estimate for the entropy of $F^i(X)$ as

$$n-\lg f_i \approx n+1-\lg(i).$$

Plugging in $n=128$ in your particular problem, we get $129-\lg(i)$ as an estimate of the entropy after $i$ iterations. This is within $\pm 1$ bit of my estimate at the top of the answer.

Incidentally, I have in my notes that a better approximation is $f_i \sim 2/(i+\log(i))$, but I don't know where I got this from, so it might be faulty. If that approximation is accurate, then a better estimate of the entropy of $F^i(X)$ is $n+1-\lg(i+\log(i))$.

Again, as a reminder, all of these estimates are only intended to be used when $i$ gets large (but not crazy large). When $i$ is small, you can calculate $f_i$ directly using the recurrence relation above. And all of these estimates are just estimates, that rely upon several approximations, which may be pretty crude.

My thanks to @fgrieu for helpful comments on this answer.

D.W.
  • 36,982
  • 13
  • 107
  • 196