Questions tagged [decidability]

Use this tag for questions about the existence of an algorithm that can and will return a correct true or false value to a decision problem.

In logic, the term decidable refers to the decision problem, the question of the existence of an effective method for determining membership in a set of formulas, or, more precisely, an algorithm that can and will return a Boolean true or false value that is correct (instead of looping indefinitely, crashing, returning "don't know," or returning a wrong answer). Logical systems such as propositional logic are decidable if membership in their set of logically valid formulas (or theorems) can be effectively determined. A theory (set of sentences closed under logical consequence) in a fixed logical system is decidable if there is an effective method for determining whether arbitrary formulas are included in the theory. Many important problems are undecidable, that is, it has been proven that no effective method for determining membership can exist for them.

342 questions
27
votes
5 answers

Is there a statement whose undecidability is undecidable?

We know there are statements that are undecidable/independent of ZFC. Can there be a statement S, such that (ZFC $\not\vdash$ S and ZFC $\not\vdash$ ~S) is undecidable?
Zirui Wang
  • 1,547
22
votes
1 answer

Are there statements that are undecidable but not provably undecidable

This is a variant of Is there a statement whose undecidability is undecidable? and Can it be shown that ZFC has statements which cannot be proven to be independent, but are? (but is not asked or answered in either of those threads). Call a formula…
Ewan Delanoy
  • 63,436
18
votes
3 answers

Is everything provable as true, false, or undecidable?

Is it possible to know whether any and all statements are true, false, or undecidable under standard mathematical axioms, e.g. ZF?
17
votes
3 answers

Decidability vs Completeness

I am trying to clear up the distinction between decidability and completeness. Decidable A theory T is decidable if there exists an effective procedure to determine whether $T\vdash\varphi$ where $\varphi$ is any sentence of the language.…
user553664
17
votes
5 answers

How could the Collatz conjecture possibly be undecidable?

I wonder how the Collatz conjecture could possibly be undecidable. Let's say it's undecidable, then no counter example can ever be found, and that to me seems to imply that none exist, and thus that it's true.
user2520938
  • 7,503
15
votes
1 answer

Are the algebraic real numbers an automatic structure?

In the 1950's, Julius Büchi showed that $(\mathbb{N},S,+,0)$ is not merely a decidable structure as Presburger had shown, but an automatic structure, i.e. there is an encoding of the natural numbers (using finite binary strings) such that you can…
15
votes
2 answers

Gödel's completeness theorem and the undecidability of first-order logic

I'm working through this module, "Undecidability of First-Order Logic" and would love to talk about the two exercises given immediately after the statement of Godel's completeness theorem. First, note Definition 2.1 from the text: A sentence…
14
votes
2 answers

Does there exist a computer program that is able to determine whether a given function is uniformly continuous?

I was wondering if someone might know whether there exists (or whether it is even possible) for a computer program to process a given function and determine whether it is uniformly continuous. I have tried to search for a question that might have…
14
votes
4 answers

The word problem for finite groups

The word problem for finite groups is decidable. Is it obvious that this is true? In particular, I'm not entirely sure about what it means for the problem to be decidable (in this case---I think I understand what decidable means in general). I…
14
votes
3 answers

Is there a decision procedure for intuitionistic propositional logic?

Is intutionistic propositional logic decidable? If so, what is a decision procedure for it, like tableaux for classical propositional logic? EDIT: In the first revision I mistook "predicate" for "propositional".
13
votes
1 answer

Why is it that most mathematical statements that mathematicians tend to study are decidable?

This is a bit of a philosophical question. Due to Gödel, we know that there are undecidable statements in ZFC set theory. But why is it that most statements that mathematicians tend to study in practice are decidable? Is it something to do with the…
user107952
  • 23,768
12
votes
1 answer

Example of incomplete, but decidable theory, and of complete and undecidable theory, question

On wikipedia it is written that Decidability should not be confused with completeness. For example, the theory of algebraically closed fields is decidable but incomplete, whereas the set of all true first-order statements about nonnegative integers…
11
votes
0 answers

Is mate-in-$n$ problem for Trappist-1 undecidable?

Trappist-1 is a variant of infinite chess that has a piece called huygens which leaps any prime number of squares orthogonally. To actually implement this game, it should have decidable mate-in-$0$ (checkmate detection) and stalemate-in-$0$…
11
votes
3 answers

I am looking for class of math problems which are provable in ZF if and only if they are provable in ZFC

I know that P vs NP and Riemannian hypothesis are of this class but could not find any article on that. I would also appriciate links or books on related theme. My question is: what are some other problems of the same class and how one proves such…
11
votes
1 answer

What is wrong with this naive approach to Hilbert's 10th problem?

Background: I have been studying some decidability results in number theory. In doing so, I have always assumed there was no need for me to study pedantic definitions of decidability using Turing machines or similar, since the naive idea of an…
1
2 3
22 23