Please help me find all natural numbers $x$ so that $x^2+x+1$ is the cube of a prime number.
(Used in here)
- 140,055
- 5,119
-
5@Prism What about $x=18$? We get $324+18+1=343=7^3$. – Potato May 17 '13 at 07:16
-
I don't see any reason to expect this to have a nice answer, unless it's from a math contest or something like that. Primes are funky. – Potato May 17 '13 at 07:19
-
Well when i was solving another problem, i came up with this. However no possible solutions came into my mind that's why i posted it in here. – CODE May 17 '13 at 11:54
2 Answers
By Ljunggren (1942), the equation $x^2+x+1=y^3$ has only these integer solutions: $(x,y)=(0,1)(-1,1)(18,7)(-19,7).$
- 16,048
-
1Awesome! I'm having a bit of trouble finding the paper. Do you happen to have an online source? – user47805 May 17 '13 at 09:35
-
1@user47805,sorry,I can't find it,too.It's not write in English.I find this result (without a proof) in another book. – lsr314 May 17 '13 at 10:11
-
-
-
The Ljunggren paper seems to be hard to find [in the online world]. Cf. https://mathoverflow.net/q/362829/27465. See however https://www.jstor.org/stable/24489702 which is a follow-up paper. – Torsten Schoeneberg Jul 27 '24 at 16:17
This is never a complete solution, but larger than the size that a comment can afford
If $x^2+x+1=p^3$ where $p$ is prime.
Clearly, $p\ne2$
As $p$ divides $x^2+x+1,p$ will divide $(x-1)(x^2+x+1)=x^3-1$
$\implies x^3\equiv1\pmod p\implies ord_px=3\implies 3$ divides $p-1$
So, prime $p=3q+1$ for some natural number $q$
As, $p>2$ i.e., odd, $p$ can be written as $6r+1$ for some natural number $r$
Now, $x^2+x=p^3-1=(6r+1)^3-1=18r(12r^2+6r+1)$
Observe that $(18r,12r^2+6r+1)=1$
As $(x,x+1)=1,$
$x,x+1$ can be $18r,12r^2+6r+1$
$\implies 12r^2+6r+1-(18r)=x+1-x=1$
$\implies 12r^2-12r=0\implies r=1$ as $r>0$
Now, we can test for other obvious combinations unless we can factorize $12r^2+6r+1$
$x=2r,x+1=9(12r^2+6r+1)$
$x=9r,x+1=2(12r^2+6r+1)$
etc.
- 279,016
-
This seems to be a research problem but you seem to have partially cracked it.(+1) – Inceptio May 17 '13 at 15:22